DHS Secretary Noem and Illinois Gov. Pritzker spar over state's immigration policies: "Performing for Fox News"
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem visited Springfield, Illinois, on Wednesday, and slammed the state's Democratic leaders for Illinois' sanctuary policies protecting undocumented immigrants.
Before she spoke, Illinois Democratic Gov. JB Pritzker's office said Noem's office does not communicate with them, and has not asked for support or coordination to enforce immigration laws.
Noem stood in front of families who've lost loved ones after incidents involving immigrants who lack legal status.
Standing alongside a handful of Illinois Republican state lawmakers, Noem criticized Pritzker, claiming Illinois doesn't protect its citizens, and demanded the state change.
"I'm calling on Gov. Pritzker and all the other leaders of this state to abandon their dangerous sanctuary policies," she said. "I'm thankful for all the state leaders that are standing behind me who agree as well. They have been fighting an uphill battle with this governor, and I'm proud of them that they're standing here with us today and with these angel families, and saying enough is enough. We have to change as a state."
In response to Noem's visit, the governor criticized the Trump administration's immigration policies, saying some of their efforts to deport migrants have been unconstitutional.
"The Trump Administration is violating the United States Constitution, denying people due process, and disappearing law-abiding neighbors – including children who are U.S. citizens. Yet, they are taking no real action to promote public safety and deport violent criminals within the clear and defined legal process," Pritzker said in a statement.
Pritzker's office has defended the state's sanctuary law, known as the Illinois Trust Act.
"The Illinois Trust Act – which was bipartisan and signed into law by a Republican – is fully compliant with federal law. Despite the rhetoric of Republicans in Congress, this public safety law ensures law enforcement can focus on doing their jobs well while empowering all members of the public, regardless of immigration status, to feel comfortable calling police officers and emergency services if they are in need of help," Pritzker spokesman Alex Gough said.
The Illinois Trust Act largely prohibits state, county, and local law enforcement agencies from cooperating with Immigration and Customs Enforcement in cases of civil immigration enforcement activities, but not in cases involving a criminal warrant or other court order.
In cases where an undocumented immigrant has been arrested, ICE officials might issue a detainer asking police to hold them for 48 hours until ICE agents can take them into federal custody, but the Illinois TRUST Act prohibits such cooperation, except in cases where the person faces a federal criminal arrest warrant.
In a statement, Pritzker called Noem's visit a publicity stunt that does "not make our communities safer or our immigration system smarter."
"Illinois doesn't need to abuse power or ignore the Constitution to keep our people safe. Like the millions of Americans asking for sensible, humane immigration reform, I encourage the Secretary to spend less time performing for Fox News and more time protecting the Homeland," Pritzker said. "Secretary Noem must have not realized she was visiting during Latino Unity Day where we come together celebrate the vibrancy and diversity of our community. Today, Secretary Noem was met by a force stronger than her: the people of Illinois. Illinoisans are sending a clear message to Trump's lackeys that we will not let you mess with us without a resistance."
Illinois Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias also wasted no time hitting back against Noem, saying she's traveling the country instead of doing her job.
Giannoulias also accused her of weaponizing Wednesday's Real ID deadline — which requires people to have advanced identification in order to fly — to create fear.
"The combination of cowardice, incompetence, and cruelty is a very scary mix," he said. "We need to step up as a society, as a country, as a democracy to monsters like Kristi Noem who don't care about people."
He argued Noem's messaging around the enforcement of the Real ID was creating more panic for people who don't need the identification.
Giannoulias reiterated that his office is working to make sure they can serve everyone seeking to get a Real ID.
Fact-checking Noem's claims during her visit to Springfield
Part of the Real ID's aim is to keep Americans safer and to make forgery of documents harder.
Noem came to Springfield to talk about the program and how she says Illinois is failing residents.
CBS News Chicago Political Reporter Chris Tye did a fact check on her comments to help clear the air and set records straight.
Noem spoke for about 20 minutes, and a lot was said; some truthful, some not.
She spoke near the home of Emma Shafer, who was stabbed to death in Springfield last year.
"This is the block where a young woman was killed. Just a couple of houses away from here, Emma Shafer was brutally stabbed and murdered by an illegal alien released into the United States by the Biden administration," Noem said.
Police suspect Shafer was killed by her ex-boyfriend, Gabriel Calixto Pichardo, who was born in Mexico, and brought to the U.S. by his mother as a child. He was later granted legal DACA status, but his status has expired, and he was no longer eligible for DACA status because of a felony conviction.
While Noem was speaking on the same block where Shafer was killed, she was unaware Shaver's family was across town on Wednesday, protesting her visit to Springfield.
"No, I wasn't aware of that," Noem said.
Other questions and topics Noem discussed detailed costs of care provided to undocumented immigrants in Illinois.
"In 2020, Governor Pritzker expanded access to taxpayer-funded free health care for illegal aliens. It has cost the citizens of Illinois $1.6 billion," Noem said.
That's true. In a February 2025 report, the Illinois Auditor General revealed a pair of state-funded health insurance programs for undocumented immigrants cost the state $1.6 billion, far more than estimated when the programs began.
Cost overruns were particularly high when it came to care for those ages 42 to 54, with costs running 286% higher than the governor forecasted.
Noem zeroed in on the governor in other ways, too.
"It is very clear that he is violating the Constitution of the United States, because it is a federal law that the federal government and the president set and enforce immigration policies," she said.
How true is that? CBS News Chicago took the question to the former dean of Northwestern University's law school.
"As you know this matter is in litigation, active litigation; which is to say the federal government has sued the state of Illinois," Northwestern University School of Law professor Daniel Rodriguez said. "The courts will decide this issue."
Pritzker repeatedly has said the state's sanctuary law, the Illinois Trust Act, is fully compliant with federal law.
Noem also claimed the Trump administration has "given the American people the safest and most secure border in American history."
"We have to double down at removing dangerous criminals," she said.
It's mostly true that the border is the most secure it's ever been.
During some months in recent years, illegal border crossings exceeded 300,000, and that number has fallen to about 8,000, but the sharpest declines in illegal border crossings came during the final months of the Biden administration.
